Scotty Cameron Newport 2 vs Odyssey Ai-ONE #1: Which Blade Wins?

This is the matchup. Two Anser-style blade putters from the two biggest names in putting. The Scotty Cameron Studio Style Newport 2 — the putter shape that Tiger Woods made legendary, rebuilt for 2025 with a Studio Carbon Steel insert. And the Odyssey Ai-ONE #1 — a classic heel-toe weighted blade with an AI-designed face insert that claims to make off-center putts travel closer to their intended distance.

We handle both of these at Golf Club Brokers constantly. They’re among the most bought and sold blade putters on the market. So which one should you actually put in your bag?

Let’s compare them where it matters: specs, feel, forgiveness, looks, value, and who each one is really built for.

Specs at a Glance

Feel and Sound: Where Cameron Wins

Here’s the thing — feel is subjective, but there’s a consensus among golfers who’ve hit both. The Newport 2 feels more premium. The Studio Carbon Steel insert with chain-link milling produces a soft, muted impact that has just enough crispness to provide feedback without any harshness. With a firmer ball, it’s slightly more crisp. With a softer ball, it’s pillowy. Either way, it feels expensive.

The Ai-ONE #1 feels good — the White Hot urethane backing delivers that familiar soft Odyssey feel that millions of golfers love. It’s quiet, responsive, and comfortable. But side by side with the Cameron, the Odyssey feels slightly less refined. There’s a tiny bit more “click” to the Ai-ONE’s impact sound compared to the Cameron’s deeper, more muffled tone.

If you’re the kind of golfer who values feel above everything else on the green, the Newport 2 wins this category clearly. It’s what you’re paying the premium for.

Forgiveness: Where Odyssey Wins

This is the Ai-ONE’s strongest argument. The AI-designed aluminum contours behind the face create variable thickness patterns that normalize ball speed across the face. Miss the center by a quarter inch, and the ball still rolls roughly the same distance as a pure strike. Odyssey claims putts finish up to 21% closer to the hole from 32 feet — a number based on robot testing against a traditional milled face.

The Newport 2, by contrast, is a traditional milled blade. It’s precise and rewards good contact beautifully, but off-center strikes lose more energy than with the Ai-ONE. The difference is most noticeable on longer putts (20+ feet) where even small speed inconsistencies translate into meaningful distance errors.

For a golfer who’s honest about their strike pattern — and most of us miss the center more often than we think — the Ai-ONE offers a real performance advantage in distance control on mishits. The Newport 2 plus models with their aluminum sole plate add some forgiveness over the standard Newport 2, but still can’t match what AI variable-thickness technology does.

Looks and Craftsmanship

The Newport 2 looks like a premium putter. The misted stainless steel finish, red cherry dot accents in the cavity, 7 Point Crown engraving on the face, and the overall proportions — it’s unmistakably Scotty Cameron. The slightly thicker topline on the 2025 Studio Style version gives it a confident, stable look at address without being bulky. Precision-milled and assembled in the USA from 303 stainless steel. Every detail is considered.

The Ai-ONE #1 takes a different approach. The navy blue PVD finish is modern and distinctive — you either love it or you don’t. The Ai Window in the cavity is a cool visual touch that shows the AI insert contours. The overall build quality is good for the price point, but it’s a cast body versus the Cameron’s milled body. You can see and feel that difference in the finishing details.

This isn’t a knock on Odyssey. It’s a $300 putter competing with a $500 putter. The Cameron should look and feel more premium, and it does.

Weight Adjustability

Both putters offer adjustable weighting, but the systems differ. The Newport 2 has tungsten sole weights in the heel and toe that can be swapped through Scotty’s Custom Shop — not quite as grab-and-go as the Odyssey system.

The Ai-ONE #1 includes interchangeable front weights in 5g, 10g, 15g, and 20g options. You can swap them yourself to dial in head weight preference. For a golfer who wants to experiment with swing weight, the Odyssey system is more accessible.

Value and Resale

The Newport 2 retails around $500. The Ai-ONE #1 retails around $300. That’s a significant gap.

On resale, the Cameron holds value dramatically better. A two-year-old Newport 2 in good condition retains 60–70% of its original value. A two-year-old Odyssey blade might retain 40–50%. So the true cost of ownership — what you pay minus what you get back when you sell — actually narrows the gap between the two putters. But the upfront investment is still meaningfully different.

If you’re budget-conscious and want the best technology-per-dollar, the Ai-ONE #1 is hard to beat. If you view a putter as a long-term investment, the Cameron’s resale value makes the higher price more palatable.

Who Should Buy Which?

Choose the Scotty Cameron Newport 2 if:

• Feel and sound quality are your top priority
• You value premium craftsmanship, USA-milled construction, and brand prestige
• You have a slight arc putting stroke
• You want a putter that holds its resale value exceptionally well
• You’re a purist who doesn’t need technology to compensate for off-center strikes

Choose the Odyssey Ai-ONE #1 if:

• Forgiveness and distance control consistency matter most to you
• You want AI-designed face technology that normalizes ball speed on mishits
• You prefer an accessible price point without sacrificing tour-quality performance
• You want easily interchangeable head weights you can swap yourself
• You have a moderate to strong arc putting stroke (47° toe hang)

Our Honest Take

Both putters are excellent. You will putt well with either one.

The Cameron wins on feel, craftsmanship, prestige, and resale. The Odyssey wins on forgiveness, technology, value, and weight adjustability. They’re optimized for different priorities, not different skill levels.

If you’re buying used, the gap narrows further. A previous-gen Cameron (Super Select or Special Select Newport 2) is available at or near the Ai-ONE’s retail price, and you get the Cameron build quality with the used-market discount. Meanwhile, used Ai-ONE putters are available at genuine bargain levels.

Try both if you can. Putting is personal. The one that looks right, feels right, and inspires confidence when you stand over it is the right one — regardless of what the spec sheet says.

Related Articles

• Scotty Cameron: The Complete Putter Brand Guide (2026)
• Best Putters for Every Budget (2026)
• How to Get Fit for Golf Clubs (And Why It Matters)

Shop Both at Golf Club Brokers

We carry authenticated Scotty Cameron Newport putters across every generation and Odyssey Ai-ONE putters in every head shape. Both new and used. Every putter is inspected, graded, and ready to ship.

Shop Scotty Cameron Putters Shop Odyssey Putters Sell or Trade In Your Putter — Get a Free Quote