Best Putters Under $200: New and Used Picks for 2026
A Scotty Cameron costs $500. An Odyssey Ai-ONE Milled runs $450. A Bettinardi will set you back $400. And for what? The same 3.5° of loft hitting a ball that’s already on the ground.
Look — premium putters feel incredible. We won’t pretend they don’t. But here’s what we know from handling thousands of putters at Golf Club Brokers: the performance gap between a $500 putter and a $150 putter is far smaller than the performance gap between a $500 driver and a $150 driver. Putters don’t generate ball speed. They don’t launch the ball into the air. They roll it on the ground. And modern budget putters do that very, very well.
This guide covers two categories: the best new putters under $200, and the best used putters under $200 — which is where the real value lives. A used putter that originally cost $350 and is now available for $150 plays identically to when it was new. Putters don’t wear out.
TL;DR: Best new blade under $200: Cleveland HB Soft 2 #1 (~$150). Best new mallet under $200: Cleveland HB Soft 2 #10.5 (~$150) or Odyssey DFX #7 (~$130). Best value under $100: Wilson Staff Infinite Bean (~$100). Best used premium under $200: Odyssey Ai-ONE (original, ~$150–180 used) or a used TaylorMade Spider Tour (~$150). Best used blade under $200: Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 (~$180–200 used). Putters don’t wear out — the used market is where the smartest putter money gets spent.
Best New Putters Under $200
| Putter | Type | Approx. Price | Key Feature | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cleveland HB Soft 2 | Blade / Mallet | ~$150 | Diamond-pattern milled face, SOFT technology, multiple shapes | Best overall value; consistent feel across the face; includes headcover |
| Odyssey DFX | Blade / Mallet | ~$130 | Soft insert, classic Odyssey feel, 5 head shapes | Odyssey fans on a budget; great feel; 2-Ball option available |
| Wilson Staff Infinite | Mallet | ~$100–130 | CNC milled, counterbalance technology, oversized grip option | Best under $100; excellent stability; Bean and Buckingham shapes |
| Odyssey White Hot OG | Blade / Mallet | ~$170–180 | Original White Hot insert, tour-proven shapes | Golfers who love classic White Hot feel; pushes the $200 ceiling |
| Cleveland Frontline | Blade / Mallet | ~$150 | Forward CG, tungsten weighting, reduces face twisting | Golfers who three-putt often; CG forward design helps speed consistency |
| TaylorMade Bandon 3 | Mallet | ~$150 | Sandstone finish, mallet with blade-like feel, toe hang | Golfers transitioning from blade to mallet; unique aesthetic |
| Sub 70 Sycamore | Blade / Mallet | ~$150–170 | CNC milled from single piece carbon steel, DTC value | Golfers who want premium milled feel without the premium price tag |
Our Top Pick: Cleveland HB Soft 2
We keep coming back to this one. The Cleveland HB Soft 2 is available in blade (#1, #8) and mallet (#10.5, Mallet 1) shapes, features a diamond-pattern milled face with Cleveland’s Speed Optimized Face Technology, and comes with a headcover — all around $150. The face consistency is surprisingly good for the price. Distance control from 20–40 feet felt comparable to putters twice the cost in our experience.
For golfers who want a mallet, the #10.5 shape is the standout. Wide footprint, easy alignment, high MOI for stability on mishits. It’s one of those putters where you wonder why anyone would spend more.
Best Under $100: Wilson Staff Infinite Bean
The Bean gets slept on. CNC milled hitting area, counterbalance weighting, and a high-contrast alignment system for about $100. The oversized grip option is great for golfers who grip too tightly or have arthritis. Wilson’s Infinite line doesn’t get the brand hype of Odyssey or TaylorMade, but the performance-per-dollar is excellent.
The Used Market: Where $200 Buys $400 Performance
Here’s the GCB advantage. Putters. Don’t. Wear. Out.
A putter that was $350 new two years ago plays exactly the same today as when it was unboxed. The face doesn’t lose speed. The insert doesn’t degrade (for at least several years of normal use). The weight doesn’t change. The only things that wear are the grip (easily replaced for $10–15) and cosmetic finish (which doesn’t affect performance).
That makes the used putter market the single best value in golf equipment. Here’s what $200 gets you:
| Used Putter | Original Retail | Used Price | What You Get | Why It’s a Great Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Odyssey Ai-ONE (2023) | $300 | ~$150–180 | AI-designed insert, tour tech, multiple shapes | Full AI forgiveness at half the new price; plays identically to new |
| TaylorMade Spider Tour | $350 | ~$140–180 | Tour-proven high MOI, Pure Roll insert | One of the most trusted mallet designs ever; exceptional stability |
| Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 | $425 | ~$180–220 | Fully milled 303 stainless, no insert, Cameron craftsmanship | Cameron quality at Odyssey pricing; may need regripping |
| Odyssey Stroke Lab / Triple Track | $250–300 | ~$80–130 | Multi-material shaft for tempo, Triple Track alignment | Excellent technology at rock-bottom used prices |
| Ping Sigma 2 / Fetch | $200–250 | ~$80–130 | Adjustable-length shaft, dual-durometer face, Ping quality | Ping’s adjustable technology at a fraction; multiple shapes |
| Odyssey White Hot Pro | $200–250 | ~$60–100 | Classic White Hot feel, proven shapes | The best sub-$100 used putter; feel is timeless |
That Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 for under $200? It was a $425 putter two years ago. The milling hasn’t changed. The weight hasn’t changed. The Cameron engraving is still on the sole. You’re getting a premium milled putter for less than the price of a new Cleveland. That’s the used market working in your favor.
How to Choose: Blade vs. Mallet at This Price
This isn’t about “better” — it’s about your stroke.
- Blade putters have toe hang, which suits arc putting strokes (face opens on the backswing, closes through impact). They offer more feel and feedback. If you’re a feel-first putter, go blade.
- Mallet putters tend to be more face-balanced, which suits straight-back-straight-through strokes. They offer more forgiveness and alignment assistance. If you three-putt often, go mallet.
The honest truth? Most golfers — especially high handicappers — putt better with a mallet. The alignment aids and higher MOI help more than the extra “feel” of a blade. But putting is deeply personal. If you look down at a mallet and hate it, you won’t putt well with it regardless of the specs. Confidence matters more than technology on the green.
What to Check When Buying a Used Putter
Used putters are almost always a great buy, but check these things:
- Face condition — Look for deep gouges, dents, or (on insert putters) separation between the insert and body. Light ball marks are normal and don’t affect performance.
- Shaft straightness — Roll the shaft on a flat surface. Any wobble means it’s bent. A bent putter shaft throws off alignment.
- Grip condition — Worn grips are cheap to replace ($10–15 for a new putter grip). Don’t let a worn grip stop you from buying an otherwise excellent used putter.
- Weight ports — On putters with adjustable sole weights, make sure the weights are present and the screws aren’t stripped.
- Headcover — Some used putters come without headcovers. Not a performance issue, but it affects resale value — especially for Scotty Cameron, where the headcover can be worth $30–50 on its own.
The Bottom Line: $200 Goes Further Than You Think
The putter market has a unique dynamic. New budget putters from Cleveland, Odyssey, and Wilson are genuinely good — far better than budget putters from even five years ago. The technology has trickled down effectively.
But the real magic is in used putters. Because putters don’t wear out, a $350 putter that’s been played for two years performs identically to a new one. The depreciation is entirely about perception and model currency — not performance. That means your $200 can buy what was a $300–$425 putter just 18–24 months ago. No other club category offers this kind of value.
Our advice? Set your budget, try both new and used options, and buy whatever feels right when you stand over a 6-footer. That’s the putter that’s going to save you strokes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a $150 putter as good as a $500 putter?
On pure performance, the gap is small. A $500 putter offers superior feel, premium materials, refined finishing, and better resale value. But the ball doesn’t know what you paid. A well-fitted $150 putter that you’re confident with will score just as well as a Scotty Cameron you’re unsure about. Confidence and fit matter more than price.
Should I buy a new cheap putter or a used premium putter?
Used premium, almost every time. A used Odyssey Ai-ONE or TaylorMade Spider Tour at $150 was designed with tour-level technology and built from better materials than most new $150 putters. Putters don’t wear out, so the used putter plays identically to new. Budget for a $10–15 regrip and you’ve got a putter that punches well above its price.
What’s the best putter shape for a beginner?
A mallet with clear alignment aids. The larger head is more forgiving on mishits, and the visual alignment cues help beginners start the ball on line. The Cleveland HB Soft 2 #10.5 or Odyssey DFX #7 are excellent starting points under $200.
Do I need to get fitted for a putter?
Ideally, yes. Length is the most important fitting variable — a putter that’s too long or too short forces you to adjust your posture and eye position, which hurts consistency. Most golfers are between 33” and 35”. Even a quick 10-minute putter fitting at a golf shop can confirm the right length and head style for your stroke.
How much does it cost to regrip a putter?
A new putter grip costs $5–15 for the grip itself, plus $3–5 for installation at a pro shop. If you DIY, it’s just the grip cost. This is a small investment that can transform a used putter with a worn grip into one that feels fresh and confident in your hands.
Are Kirkland putters any good?
Yes. The Kirkland Signature putter offers CNC milling, decent feel, and solid alignment for around $100. It’s not going to compete with a milled Scotty Cameron on feel, but for the price, it’s an excellent entry-level option. The grip is slightly thin and may benefit from replacement, but the head performs well beyond its price point.
Related Articles
- Scotty Cameron: The Complete Putter Brand Guide (2026)
- Odyssey: The Complete Putter Brand Guide (2026)
- Scotty Cameron Newport 2 vs Odyssey Ai-ONE #1
- How to Build a Golf Bag on a Budget
- When and How to Regrip Your Golf Clubs
We carry hundreds of used putters from Scotty Cameron, Odyssey, TaylorMade, Ping, Cleveland, and more — many under $200. Every putter is inspected for face condition, shaft straightness, weight port integrity, and grip wear. Find a tour-quality putter at a budget-friendly price.